Yes and no.
You use these words all the time, but how often do you think about them? They’re not nouns, they’re not verbs, so what are they? Why do we nod our heads yes and shake our heads no? And what’s the deal with yeah no?
Linguist Daniel Midgley explains it all on this episode of Talk the Talk.
Listen to this episode
Ben wondered whether we could do a whole based on two words, but we did it. It was easy, since it’s two of the richest and most interesting words in English: yes and no. And I liked getting to the bottom of the quasi-Australian expression yeah no.
The sad news is that Marcia Wallace (Miss Krabappel of the Simpsons) has passed on. I try to work the word cromulent into conversations whenever I can, so this was a sad one for me.
I actually can’t watch this; it’s too painful! Yes, Harry and hairy are pronounced differently in some varieties of English, but not in all. In fact, my variety — Pacific Northwest English — has the Mary/marry/merry merger, so we say them all the same. And yet here’s the host Tom Kennedy, trying to explain phonology terribly, appealing to authority all the while. Aaargh! Time to invent that time machine.
The school that banned texting during breaks
More thoughts from my blog
English used to have a four-part system with yes, yea, no, and nay.
And what’s the deal with aye?
What part of speech is yes and no?
Why do we nod ‘yes’ and shake ‘no’?
Darwin thought it was innate. Search on this page for ‘Signs of affirmation or approval, and of negation or disapproval: nodding and shaking the head.‘
For Bulgarians, it’s the opposite.
Burridge and Florey’s treatment of yeah-no: “Yeah-no, he’s a good kid.” (Paywall.)
It’s kind of Australian,
Ben Yagoda’s take
Embiggen and cromulent appeared in this episode of the Simpsons.
Here’s the clip:
‘Say Yes’ by Elliott Smith
from the album Either/Or
‘There’s No Other Way’ by Blur
from the album Leisure